econoTwist's

Posts Tagged ‘Dublin’

IMF Put Irish Bailout On Hold

In Financial Markets, International Econnomic Politics, Law & Regulations, National Economic Politics, Quantitative Finance on 10.12.10 at 16:54
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has decided to postpone its approval of the Irish bailout until its been approved by the Irish parliament – Dàil – hopefully after the debate next Wednesday, an IMF spokesperson says in a short  statement issued today.
.
“Assuming parliamentary support for the package, the Managing Director could recommend approval by the IMF Executive Board of the proposed €22.5 billion IMF loan as early as December 16.”
.

The International Monetary Fund


The Government of Ireland decided yesterday to table a motion on the EU-IMF Financial Assistance Program for Ireland in the Irish Parliament (Dáil). The vote on this motion is scheduled for Wednesday, December 15, 2010. Today the IMF has issued the following statement:
.

“The authorities have informed us that while parliamentary approval of the EU-IMF support package is not legally required, the Irish Government has put the motion before parliament to strengthen political support for the agreement.  In deference to Ireland’s parliamentary process, the IMF has decided to postpone consideration by its Board of the proposed loan under the Extended Fund Facility until after the debate. Assuming parliamentary support for the package, the Managing Director could recommend approval by the IMF Executive Board of the proposed €22.5 billion IMF loan as early as December 16.”

“We welcome the first implementation measures of the 2011 budget – stipulating the fiscal consolidation path and important reform measures involved in the program – have recently been passed by the Irish Parliament, confirming Ireland’s strong commitment to the program and the policies involved.”

.

.

Advertisements

Another Sunday – Another EU Crisis Meeting

In Financial Markets, Health and Environment, International Econnomic Politics, Law & Regulations, National Economic Politics, Views, commentaries and opinions on 28.11.10 at 14:35

The “Informal” Eurogroup and the ECOFIN are meeting today, Sunday, at the EU headquarter in Brussels.The informal group meeting officially starts at 15 PM (CET) , the ECOFIN meeting is set to open at 16 PM. On the agenda is, among other things, the final approval of the Irish bailout. (Please, don’t ask me how an informal group can approve an official international bailout!)

The Informal Euro Group

It’s not clear whether the meeting will be broadcasted LIVE, or not. If it does, I’ll add a link here on this page. However, several of the EU ministers made short comments when they arrived on doorstep at the EU headquarter in Brussels earlier today.

Here’s French finance minister Christine Lagarde:

Vodpod videos no longer available.

.
.

Here’s Belgium’s deputy prime minister, Dider Reynders, making comments before the Eurogroup and ECOFIN meeting on 28 November in Brussels:

Vodpod videos no longer available.

.

.

Elena Salgado, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Economy of Spain, made the following remarks when arriving Brussels:

Vodpod videos no longer available.

.
.

Wolfgang Schauble, federal minister for finance of Germany arriving in Brussels:

Vodpod videos no longer available.

.
.

Vice Chancellor and Federal Minister for Finance of Austria, Josef Prôll, comments at the arrival in Brussels before today’s Eurogroup/ ECOFIN meeting:

Vodpod videos no longer available.

.
.
One of the last to arrive Brussels this Sunday is UK’s Chancellor of the exchequer of the United Kingdom, George Osborne:
Vodpod videos no longer available. 

.

    .

    Select Your Language:

    English * Arabic * Chinese * Danish * French * German * Hebrew * Italian * Japanese * Norwegian * Portuguese * Russian * Spanish * Swedish * Turkish

    Saving Irish Banks Bondholders Is A "Disgrace"

    In Financial Markets, International Econnomic Politics, National Economic Politics, Views, commentaries and opinions on 06.10.10 at 01:39

    Says Financial Times Deutschland commentator, Wolfgang Munchau, with whom I agree with in most issues. However, when it come to the well-being of Irish bondholders, I don’t have enough information to form an opinion. So, read this interesting post by Mr, Munchau and decide for yourself.

    “For a risk-averse politician, dumping the cost on the taxpayer is easy. For the economy it is a nightmare. It is also politically dangerous in the long run, as the distributional unfairness will favor extremist political parties.”

    Wolfgang Munchau


    No matter how much debt you might have, there always exists a projected income growth rate at which you can pretend to be solvent. The projected rate of growth is the issue on which I differ most with those who claim that Ireland is fundamentally solvent. They are moderately optimistic about future growth whereas I am not.

    The Irish government last week recognized the scale of the country’s banking problem, and it deserves credit for that. The decision to recapitalize Anglo Irish Bank, the bank at the heart of Ireland’s property meltdown, will raise the country’s deficit to 32 per cent of gross domestic product this year.

    I am not worried by that number or by the projection that the debt-to-GDP ratio is headed towards 100 per cent. What I am worried about is the combined effect of bad policies in Ireland and a deteriorating external environment on Ireland’s solvency.

    First, Dublin is still not realistic about what constitutes a worst-case scenario. A fall in commercial property prices by 65 per cent with no subsequent increase this decade hardly qualifies. This is merely a description of a medium-sized bubble – not the real-estate madness we have actually witnessed. Should that not be the central scenario?

    Second, and most important, the Irish government and several private sector economists are delusional about the effects of a financial crisis on growth. History tells us it takes a long time for economies to revert to normal after a big financial crisis. In the case of Ireland, where the crisis is one of the biggest ever recorded, a real worst-case scenario would include stagnation for up to a decade, mass emigration, further falls in house prices, a significant fall in tax revenues, more austerity in response, and the further banking problems that would result from such a toxic mix.

    I am not predicting this scenario, but it is at least as plausible as Dublin’s naively optimistic V-shape-recovery assumptions.

    Third, the monetary environment is going to be tough. The Irish government currently pays an interest rate on 10-year bonds of well over 6 per cent at a time when goods prices are stagnating and asset prices declining.

    This implies real long-term interest rates approaching double-digits. A bail-out through the European Financial Stability Facility is not going to help. The EFSF will offer finance when others do not. It will be useful when markets seize up. But rates are hardly going to be more attractive than current market rates.

    Short-term finance from the European Central Bank is still cheap, but I expect European short-term rates to go up soon. Last week, overnight euro zone interest rates had already more than doubled to 0.9 per cent.

    It looks as though the ECB is preparing the ground for a shift in monetary policy, and we should factor this into our calculations. The euro’s exchange rate is an additional source of tightness. After a brief period of weakness earlier this year, the euro is back to a level that I would consider moderately overvalued.

    So if you combine all these factors with an observed slowdown in the global economy, it is unreasonable to assume that Ireland will return to normal growth rates once the acute phase of the crisis is over. Even a decade of stagnation is hardly a worst-case scenario.

    So what should Ireland do? Recognizing the scale of the problem was a good decision.

    The fundamental problem with the Irish government’s approach was the decision to dump almost the entire adjustment burden on to the taxpayer, rather than to accept or negotiate a partial default.

    I am aware that there are legal impediments to the participation of the bondholders in the bank rescue costs. You cannot simply apply a haircut on a bond unless the issuer has formally declared bankruptcy. Dublin is now preparing legislation that would allow it to apply a haircut to the subordinate debt.

    First, coming two years after the beginning of the crisis, this is absurdly late.

    More importantly, it is just peanut-sized symbolism, especially as no haircut will be applied to holders of senior debt. My concern is that Dublin is overburdening the taxpayer, and might worsen the downward spiral.

    This is not just an Irish problem. European governments everywhere are scared of touching bondholders. I had been wondering about this default-phobia for some time.

    The most plausible explanation I have heard is based on an asymmetry of risk. Haircuts are a legal minefield, and politicians find it more expedient to dump the problem on the taxpayer than to risk a hugely damaging defeat in court. Some politicians are inclined to always agree with the last person they have spoken to, and the power of the banking lobby is clearly a factor.

    For a risk-averse politician, dumping the cost on the taxpayer is easy. For the economy it is a nightmare. It is also politically dangerous in the long run, as the distributional unfairness will favour extremist political parties.

    The European political establishment recoils so much at the idea of default, it is willing to accept extreme hardship. Just look at Latvia. But Latvian brutalism is not going to be realistic for Ireland. Brian Lenihan, the Irish finance minister, might wish to ponder whether his monumentally unfair taxpayer bail-out is what will ultimately “bring down Ireland”.

    Anglo Irish Downgraded – No Surprise

    Irish Sovereign CDS Spread Exceeds 500 Basis Points

    Ireland And Portugal Close To Collapse

    Irish CDS Spreads Back To Record High After Bond Sale

    Irish Finance Minister: Concerted Attack On The Euro Zone

    *

    Irish Finance Minister: Concerted Attack On The Euro Zone

    In Financial Markets, Health and Environment, International Econnomic Politics, National Economic Politics on 25.09.10 at 22:18

    The Irish Minister for Finance, Brian Lenihan,  says the recent surge in borrowing costs for some countries suggests there is a concerted attack on euro zone nations, warns reporters of a cosy cartel operating amongst economists and claims that the underlying trends indicates a remarkable turnaround for the Irish economy.

    “There is a concerted attack on the euro zone, there is a concentration on weaker countries.”

    Brian Lenihan


    Ireland will counter a concerted attack that is threatening the euro zone by bringing its finances in order helped by a “remarkable turnaround” in the economy, the finance minister told reporters in Dublin on Friday as he criticized journalists for overstating Ireland’s economic difficulties.

    Minister for Finance Brian Lenihan criticized some journalists for overstating Ireland’s economic difficulties to the detriment of the country, speaking at  a conference in Dublin Friday, the Irish Times reports.

    At a conference titled “Confidence in the Media” Mr Lenihan said while most reporting had been fair, journalists needed to be aware of the self-fulfilling nature of any “doomsday scenarios” they wrote.

    Journalists could undermine or promote confidence in the economy, the Irish minister stated as the price of insuring Irish government debt rose to all time high with a CDS spread of more than 500 basis points.

    Climate of Fear

    He acknowledged there was a “climate of fear” about the impact of financial markets on the economy, the loss of jobs and the stability of the banking system.

    A crucial element in dispelling fear was the provision of accurate, reliable and balanced information, he lectured the professional media workers in Dublin.

    “There is a tendency to paint black-and-white pictures, to overstate difficulties, to use sometimes emotive language. And God knows, our problems are bad enough without exaggerating the reportage to present doomsday scenarios,” he said.

    Adding that he did not agree with those who claimed the media did not report enough good news.

    It is facile to expect reporters to engage in “national back-patting,” he said,  and that journalists have to be skeptical in their treatment of stories.

    Cosy Cartel of Economists

    However, skepticism should not be reserved just for government, or political parties, and the same rigor should be applied to the reporting of interest groups and representative bodies.

    Agendas were not exclusive to politicians and governments, and many interest groups had better communication resources than political parties, the Irish minster informs. Adding that a “cosy cartel” is operation amongst  economists, whereby they do not go head to head or disagree in public.

    Euro Zone Under Attack

    Ireland will counter a concerted attack that is threatening the euro zone by bringing its finances in order, helped by a “remarkable turnaround” in the economy, the finance minister also told the media as the premium investors demand to hold 10-year Irish bonds rather than German Bunds rose to a new euro lifetime high of 451 bps, a day after a surprise fall in Ireland’s Q2 GDP  posed a new threat to Dublin’s fiscal consolidation efforts.

    Lenihan says Ireland will do its utmost to defend the euro currency from the market attack which he said was manifested in “disturbingly” high yields demanded for its bonds at sales on Tuesday.

    According to Reuters (Dublin) the finance minister told reporters on the sideline of the conference:

    “There is a concerted attack on the euro zone, there is a concentration on weaker countries.”

    A Remarkable Turnaround

    Data published Friday showed that the Irish economy contracted by 1,2%  in the second quarter of 2010, and that growth in the first quarter was less than previously estimated.

    In recent weeks the extra yield investors demand to hold Irish bonds over German bunds has surged to record highs due to investor concern about the State’s ability to manage the cost of its bank bailout and reduce the budget deficit.

    However, according to Mr. Lenihan, undeterred by the data,  the underlying trends indicates a remarkable turnaround for the economy.

    “Exports are growing. New order books are expanding and business confidence has improved markedly since last year. Tax revenues are stabilizing, public expenditure is under control and our budget deficit will shrink next year,” Lenihan says.

    Read also:  The big gamble: The inside story of the bank guarantee

    Question Of The Day

    Now, here’s the Econtwist’s Question of The Day:

    Who is best at producing conspiracy theories?

    A: Politicians?

    B: Journalists?

    C: Even?

    Related by The Econotwist:

    Irish Sovereign CDS Spread Exceeds 500 Basis Points

    Ireland And Portugal Close To Collapse

    Irish CDS Spreds Back To Record High After Bond Sale

    Media Freedom Threatened In Most European Countries

    Estonian Newspapers Protesting With Blank Front Page

    Euro Area Under Massive Speculative Attack

    Attacks Against Spanish Financial Markets?

    Traders Short Record Amount of Euro

    Dangerous Economic Misconceptions

    Are Governments Producing Conspiracy Theories?

    Markit Credit Wrap: The Week in Perspective

    *